Cruz and Co

We know tax. Let us look after yours.

  • Home
  • About
    • Meet the Team
    • Our Clients
    • Testimonials
  • Services
    • Tax Consultant and Compliance Services
    • Small Business and Sole Trader Accountant
    • Outsourced Accounting Solutions
    • Business Structure
    • Outsourced CFO
    • Working Visa Refunds
  • Resources
    • Tax Refund Process
    • Client Assistant Schedule forms
    • Downloadables
    • Helpful Links
    • Rental Property Cashflow calculator
    • SMSF Tax Refund Process
  • Contact Us
  • Blog

Connect with us

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn

ATO Announces Changes to How Penalty Relief Is Applied

By: Steve Burnham

From 1 July 2018 the ATO says it will not apply penalties to tax returns and activity statements where your clients have made an inadvertent error by failing to take reasonable care or due to the fact that they have not taken a “reasonably arguable” position (more below).

It says that if it finds inadvertent errors in your client’s tax return or activity statement, it will fix the error and contact the practitioner who lodged to make sure the client is informed about how to get it right next time.

The ATO says its penalty relief applies to eligible individuals as well as entities with a turnover of less than $10 million. These entities can be:

  • small businesses
  • SMSFs
  • strata title bodies
  • not-for-profit organisations
  • co-operatives.

Those not eligible for penalty relief include:

  • wealthy individuals and their businesses
  • associates of wealthy individuals that may be classified as a small business entity in their own right
  • entities that do not meet the small business entity eligibility criteria
  • public groups, significant global entities and associates.

The ATO points out that practitioners cannot apply for penalty relief for their clients — it will provide this during an audit if clients are eligible. If the ATO audits your clients for periods earlier than 1 July 2018, it says it will also apply penalty relief for those periods.

Relief from penalties also comes with a “reset” period, which means penalty relief will be available once every three years at most. Penalty relief is not available for example where, in the past three years, your client has:

  • had penalty relief applied
  • been penalised for reckless or intentional disregard of the law
  • evaded tax or committed fraud
  • been involved in the control or management of another entity that has evaded tax
  • incurred debts without the intention of being able to pay, such as with phoenix activity.

Penalty relief does not apply to other taxes such as fringe benefits tax (FBT) or the super guarantee (SG).

What is a reasonably arguable position?
The process for determining whether a position is “reasonably arguable” is explained to some degree in miscellaneous taxation ruling MT 2008/2. The ATO, in taxation ruling TR 94/5, states that: “Whether the taxpayer’s treatment was reasonably arguable would depend on its relative strength when compared with the Commissioner’s and other possible treatments. In other words, taxpayers should take particular note of the Commissioner’s views on the correct operation of the law as expressed in a public ruling, but may adopt alternative treatments provided there are sound reasons for doing so.”

A Treasury review of income tax self assessment found that “reasonably arguable” is only defined in general terms. This includes that “a position is reasonably arguable if it would be concluded in the circumstances, having regard to relevant authorities, that it is at least as likely to be correct as incorrect”.

The explanatory memorandum to the A New Tax System (Tax Administration) Act (No. 2) 2000 explains this concept further as follows: “The position must be a contentious area of the law, where the relevant law is unsettled or where, although the principles of the law are settled, there is a serious question about the application of those principles to the circumstances of the particular case.”

The EM further states that: “The strength of the taxpayer’s argument should be sufficient to support a reasonable expectation that the taxpayer could win in court. The taxpayer’s argument should be cogent, well-grounded and considerable in its persuasiveness.”

 

Source: Tax & Super Australia

Testimonials

  • Zac Fryer

    Director, Import and Distribution Company

    Ritchie Cruz provides and high level of accounting expertise and goes above and beyond in answering any queries we have.

    Read full testimonial
  • Jae Kwon Yoo

    Business Tax – Electrical Contractors

    Ritchie is awesome. He is very professional and responsive and he is always there to help you. He even replies during weekend. He needs some…

    Read full testimonial
  • Dr Krish Perananthan

    Cosmetic and Implant Dentistry

    Ritchie was recommended to me by my father and I have also continued to recommend him to my friends. He is reliable, efficient and has a…

    Read full testimonial
  • Kellie Pincham

    Director
    Automotive Parts Retailing business

    Cruz & Co offer a great professional and friendly service. Ritchie gave me confidence running the business knowing that he was readily available for…

    Read full testimonial
  • Regina Wang

    Business Tax – Beauty Salon 

    Ritchie has been managing my tax matters as a sole trader for 2 years+. Always very responsive to my questions and make effort to reply…

    Read full testimonial
  • Vanita Aloda

    Restaurant Owner

    Ritchie Cruz is my Accountant. We have a solid 10 year relationship.

    Ritchie as always provide me with honest and efficient service.

    Is a great communicator, always replies efficiently to…

    Read full testimonial
  • Jonathan Fambart

    Business Tax – Travel Industry

    Cruz & Co was introduced to me this year and it was the best decision for my sole trader and personal taxation affairs. Ritchie the…

    Read full testimonial
  • Napoleon Guines

    Director, Travel Company Operations

    Ritchie Cruz and Co are accommodating and have excellent service.

    Cruz & Co have impressed me the most is due to their efficient service.  They are…

    Read full testimonial
  • Daniel Robey

    I have and continue to recommend Cruz and Co to many businesses and individuals who are looking for a business advisor and accountant that goes over and above…

    Read full testimonial
  • Jonathan Yeoman

    Director, Technical Design Company

    This is a new business startup and Cruz&Co. have provided great help, guidance and reassurance from the beginning.

    Ritchie has provided us with excellent service and…

    Read full testimonial

© 2025 Cruz & Co.

  • Home
  • About
    • Meet the Team
    • Our Clients
    • Testimonials
  • Services
    • Tax Consultant and Compliance Services
    • Small Business and Sole Trader Accountant
    • Outsourced Accounting Solutions
    • Business Structure
    • Outsourced CFO
    • Working Visa Refunds
  • Resources
    • Tax Refund Process
    • Client Assistant Schedule forms
    • Downloadables
    • Helpful Links
    • Rental Property Cashflow calculator
    • SMSF Tax Refund Process
  • Contact Us
  • Blog